[2017-11-14]
Well over a century has passed since Japan fabricated a treaty, better known as “Ulsa five-point treaty”, to seek its right to colonize Korea in 1905.
Japan still refuses to admit the forcible and illegal nature of the treaty, talking about its validity as a legal agreement.
Historical facts, however, testify to the illegality of the pact.
In 1905 Ito Hirobumi came to Korea with many Japanese troops in his capacity as “ambassador extraordinary”.
At the meeting with Korean Emperor Kojong, he conveyed to him an autograph letter of the Japanese king, which said: “As I specially dispatch an ambassador for the maintenance of peace in the East, I hope you will deal with matters under his direction.”
Later, Ito went to the royal palace again to hand a draft of the treaty over to the Korean sovereign. The draft obliged Korea to appoint a Japanese as resident-general under the emperor to govern the whole country, to name Japanese administrators as managers of all ports, to transfer diplomatic rights to Tokyo, and to refrain from signing agreements with other countries without the consent of Japan. And he forced Kojong to accept the draft without condition.
As he was flatly rejected by the emperor, Ito tried in vain to persuade the ministers of the Korean feudal government at the Japanese legation.
Japanese troops thronged into the royal palace in Seoul on November 17 1905 and encircled it ring upon ring to create a gruesome atmosphere. By doing so, the Japanese brought the opposing ministers under their control before cooking up the treaty.
International law views duress as a main factor in defining the illegality of treaties. The modern international law and the Vienna treaty on treaty law stipulate that all treaties made up as a result of blackmail and duress against a state or its representative do not have any legal force.
Accordingly, the controversial treaty carries no legal binding force.
Moreover, as it failed to have the approval and signature of Emperor Kojong and the impress of the state seal, it could not take due form as a legitimate agreement.
For a treaty to have them was an inviolable principle in view of the laws of the feudal Joson dynasty and international customary laws.
The law on official document enacted by the Korean feudal government in 1894 specifies that for the ratification of the emperor’s message or treaty the state seal is to be affixed on it after he signs it. International law also states that a treaty can come into effect subject to the consent of the sovereign and it will be a scrap of paper without his ratification.
The Japanese, however, despicably stole the seal of the foreign minister and affixed it on the document as they could not have the emperor’s signature and state seal.
The treaty has no formal name either.
Conventionally, a treaty without name can neither be presented to a deliberation with other party nor be signed. That was why it was called the “Korea-Japan convention” by Japan and “Ulsa treaty” or “Ulsa five-point treaty” by feudal Joson.
Japanese jurist Matsubara Kazuo, in his essay on international law published in 1904, said that an international treaty can be effectuated only when it satisfies the five conditions—the capacity of signatories, delegation of full power, freedom of agreement, purpose and legality of conclusion, and ratification—and if even one of them is not met it is regarded as invalid.
As seen above, the “Ulsa five-point treaty” is a waste paper as it fulfils none of the conditions.
By Choe Yong Nam PT
More From Pyongyang Times
A delegation of the DPRK Ministry of External Economic Relations led by Minister Yun Jong Ho left Pyongyang by air on April 23 to
April 25, 2024
A delegation of the DPRK Ministry of External Economic Relations led by Minister Yun Jong Ho left Pyongyang by air on April 23 to
Maria Zakharova, a spokeswoman for the Russian Foreign Ministry, warned against the US military aid to Ukraine, Israel and Taiwan
April 25, 2024
Maria Zakharova, a spokeswoman for the Russian Foreign Ministry, warned against the US military aid to Ukraine, Israel and Taiwan
The DPRK health delegation led by Jong Mu Rim, minister of Public Health, returned home by air on April 23 after visiting Russia.
April 25, 2024
The DPRK health delegation led by Jong Mu Rim, minister of Public Health, returned home by air on April 23 after visiting Russia.
The anti-Japanese armed struggle was a revolutionary war to defeat Japanese imperialism and achieve the cause of Korea’s
April 25, 2024
The anti-Japanese armed struggle was a revolutionary war to defeat Japanese imperialism and achieve the cause of Korea’s
The first revolutionary armed forces in Korean history were founded on April 25 1932. In order to defend the dignity of the nation
April 25, 2024
The first revolutionary armed forces in Korean history were founded on April 25 1932. In order to defend the dignity of the nation
Palestinian President Mahmud Abbas, in an interview with the Warpa News Agency on April 20, condemned the US for its unreasonable
April 25, 2024
Palestinian President Mahmud Abbas, in an interview with the Warpa News Agency on April 20, condemned the US for its unreasonable
The idea of “The people are God” and devoted service for the good of the people are the foundation of all lines and policies of th
April 25, 2024
The idea of “The people are God” and devoted service for the good of the people are the foundation of all lines and policies of th
The participants in the second workshop of officials in the field of information work of the Workers' Party of Korea conducted
April 25, 2024
The participants in the second workshop of officials in the field of information work of the Workers' Party of Korea conducted
The Spring National Footwear Exhibition-2024 opened in Pyongyang under the sponsorship of the Ministry of Light Industry.
April 25, 2024
The Spring National Footwear Exhibition-2024 opened in Pyongyang under the sponsorship of the Ministry of Light Industry.
Sea Kumgang Gate is situated about 20 kilometres away from the county town of Kosong in Kangwon Province.The area abounds with fis
April 24, 2024
Sea Kumgang Gate is situated about 20 kilometres away from the county town of Kosong in Kangwon Province.The area abounds with fis
A delegation of the Moscow Zoo of Russia led by Director Svetlana Akulova arrived in Pyongyang by plane on April 22.
April 24, 2024
A delegation of the Moscow Zoo of Russia led by Director Svetlana Akulova arrived in Pyongyang by plane on April 22.
The 2024 Asian wrestling Olympic qualification tournament took place in Kyrgyzstan from April 19 to 21. Choe Hyo Gyong, Mun Hyon
April 24, 2024
The 2024 Asian wrestling Olympic qualification tournament took place in Kyrgyzstan from April 19 to 21. Choe Hyo Gyong, Mun Hyon
In his speech to mark the 214th anniversary of the start of struggle for national independence on April 19, the Venezuelan vice
April 24, 2024
In his speech to mark the 214th anniversary of the start of struggle for national independence on April 19, the Venezuelan vice
The Russian permanent representative to the UN censured the US for protecting Israel in the UN Security Council meeting concerning
April 24, 2024
The Russian permanent representative to the UN censured the US for protecting Israel in the UN Security Council meeting concerning
Russian President Vladimir Putin advanced the task to be tackled by the public health sector in a congratulatory message sent to
April 24, 2024
Russian President Vladimir Putin advanced the task to be tackled by the public health sector in a congratulatory message sent to
The Japanese reactionaries visited the Yasukuni Shrine keeping the name tablets of war criminals to make offerings on April 21.
April 24, 2024
The Japanese reactionaries visited the Yasukuni Shrine keeping the name tablets of war criminals to make offerings on April 21.
Now, extreme weather conditions caused by global warming have unprecedentedly frequented the world, followed by continuous
April 24, 2024
Now, extreme weather conditions caused by global warming have unprecedentedly frequented the world, followed by continuous
Farmers moved into new dwelling houses in the villages of the Sangi Industrial Crop Farm of Kujang County, North Phyongan
April 24, 2024
Farmers moved into new dwelling houses in the villages of the Sangi Industrial Crop Farm of Kujang County, North Phyongan
The second workshop of officials in the field of information work of the Workers' Party of Korea took place at the People's Palace
April 24, 2024
The second workshop of officials in the field of information work of the Workers' Party of Korea took place at the People's Palace
Ahmed Abu al-Gheit, secretary general of the League of Arab States, on April 17 said that massacre committed by Israel should be
April 24, 2024
Ahmed Abu al-Gheit, secretary general of the League of Arab States, on April 17 said that massacre committed by Israel should be
More Articles